example.com/path/to/article
000 points · username · 0 hours ago
example.com98 points · 214 comments · 4 years ago · jimhi
woodruffw
CobrastanJorji
One thing your site could do but doesn't is tell me WHERE it got that information, like exactly where. Why just say "publicly available data?" I want to know precisely where you got all this on me, with annotations. Without that information, this is just a scary page that encourages me to sign up for nebulous services.
lilsoso
I've previously spent some time manually sending CCPA deletion requests to a variety of data brokers, and I've even tried two paid services. I know the effort is pyrrhic, and there's probably no way to remove all the information.
rgovostes
The "doxx me score" gauge is cheesy, and I have a negative reaction toward seeing those from disreputable banner ads around the internet.
It's not clear to me how the service you are selling (SIM swapping protection) and the privacy report are related.
Do you want to clarify what data you are recording as part of offering this service?
We only retain collected information for as long as necessary to provide you with your requested service. What data we store, we’ll protect within commercially acceptable means to prevent loss and theft, as well as unauthorized access, disclosure, copying, use or modification.
What services are you getting the information from?
batch12
nfriedly
Some of it was from family members who were apparently conflated with me, and some of it didn't ring any bells at all.
It had all of my recent addresses, and many more that I had never heard of, including cities I've only visited once or twice and two countries I've never been to in my life.
One phone number had 4 SSN's associated with it, and while the site doesn't show you the actual digits of the SSN, it does say the state it was issued in. All 4 were from different states, and none were from the state I was actually born in.
prepend
Are you going to use these data or sell these data?
spdustin
jzig
kc10
https://www.discover.com/security/online-privacy-protection/
FiveClientAuto
tragictrash
blep_
function_seven
Unselect6889
...Looking closer at the report now, all fields which returned information were wrong. Perhaps it's returning info based on previous customers who have used the number?
Points to consider:
1) This was not my primary phone number. It's possible that a lack of activity used on the phone I tested this with made it seem like a previous owner was still the active owner? Perhaps if the service is grabbing very outdated information, there should be an indicator next to each result "Older than # of (time)".
2) A low score is red...does this mean that a low score mean that a lot of information was returned? Comparing this "doxx" to a credit card score is confusing, because a credit score is generally low because you have a lack of history. With this, your score is low because you have a lot of history. It's weird. Maybe low results should = green, with a low score; high results = red, with a high score. I see "high score" to mean "high data points".
3) Not every field was filled out for this number, but my score was deep in the red. What is the circumstance where a phone number lands in the middle? I suppose some fields might be weighted higher than others?
Edit:
(Pet peeve of mine. This isn't a personal slam against the company, just a criticism against the practice in general.)
I see you have one of those chat widgets in the bottom right. If a customer uses that, and doesn't get a response immediately, it's pointless and taking up space. If I want to send an email, I want the email address listed clearly on the contact page. A roundabout way through a psudeo-clippy thing stinks.
IYasha
coldblues
xhan0o
aojdwhsd
There was also an associated phone number that I only ever used on my credit card accounts. Hmm.
bckr
z3c0
bcrosby95
It also found the names and dates of birth of our extended families.
tedunangst
binaryblitz
piscisaureus
I tried two phone numbers: my primary cell phone number gets a great 800+ score but reveals an accurate address history of 9 years.
The second one gets a poor score (415), but none of the data is accurate. Have fun: https://gist.github.com/piscisaureus/03d5ebeeb3e77922a858464....
fortran77
KyleJune
jmorenoa88
_8j50
pbronez
I'd consider paying for a more detailed report that explains not just what can be found, but HOW that data was found, and remediation options beyond the mobile service plan.
LinkLink
rootusrootus
blobbers
349ecb77cd62
somesomething
mcdonje
gregwebs
vorpalhex
derwiki
BizarroLand
colechristensen
anecdotal1
trinovantes
ranger_danger
mesozoic
blackearl
DocJade
BoorishBears
[deleted]
Fargoan
[1]: https://www.efani.com/about-us
[2]: https://www.efani.com/leadership